The Gold Coast Field Guide
A Perfect Day
in Oyster Bay.
We've brewed beer on Audrey Avenue for over a decade. We know this town. Here's how we'd spend a Saturday in it.
Oyster Bay doesn't show off. It doesn't try to be the Hamptons, it doesn't act like Greenwich, and it definitely isn't one of those North Shore towns that's been scrubbed into irrelevance by chain stores. It's a working village with a harbor, a history, and a downtown you can actually walk.
If you've got a day to give it, here's how to spend that day well — morning to evening, sunrise yoga to last pour, with stops at every place we'd send a friend from out of town.
Stop 1 · 8:00 AM
Start slow at Oyster Bay Yoga.
Any weekend that starts with a 10 AM coffee instead of an 8 AM intention is a weekend you spend recovering from. Oyster Bay Yoga, right on Audrey Avenue, offers morning classes that are the right kind of hard — enough to earn breakfast, not so much you're wrecked for the rest of the day.
They've got flow, pilates, restorative, and meditation on the schedule, with first-timer "Welcome Sessions" for anyone who's been putting it off.
📍 9 Audrey Avenue · Their "2 weeks unlimited for $39" intro deal is a steal if you're local.
Stop 2 · 9:30 AM
Coffee on Audrey Ave.
You've got two serious options within three blocks of each other, and you should know the difference.
Southdown Coffee
49 Audrey Ave. A specialty roaster that got mentioned in Food & Wine as one of the best coffee shops in America. Single-origin beans roasted locally, hand-prepared food, pastries delivered daily. If you care about the coffee itself, this is the move.
Order the maple latte — Vermont Silloway Maple, no artificial syrups. Open 7 AM – 6 PM daily.
Karmic Grind
69 Pine Hollow Road. The newer arrival — crossed the harbor from Locust Valley in late 2025. Female-owned, Devoción beans out of Brooklyn, and the kind of space that actually wants you to sit and stay awhile.
Try The Founder — cinnamon + Vermont maple. Their most popular pour.
Our honest take: grab Southdown on your way through, Karmic Grind when you've got an hour to kill.
Stop 3 · 10:30 AM
Browse Theodore's Books.
An actual independent bookstore in 2026. You'd think they'd all gone extinct. Theodore's — named in honor of one of Oyster Bay's most famous residents — is owned by former Congressman Steve Israel and sits at 17 Audrey Avenue.
Nearly 10,000 titles across 1,500 square feet, strong in history and current events, and a curated children's section with a dedicated reading table. The store also runs a serious author event program — you'll find bestselling novelists, biographers, and political voices doing signings and discussions throughout the year.
Grab a book for the Sagamore Hill grounds later. That's a pro move. They have a sign inside that reads "No jerks allowed," which tells you most of what you need to know about the vibe.
Stop 4 · 11:30 AM
Sagamore Hill.
The one everyone comes for.
This was Theodore Roosevelt's home. The 26th president of the United States lived here from 1885 until his death in 1919, and during his presidency it was known as the Summer White House. He received foreign dignitaries on the porch, negotiated the treaty that ended the Russo-Japanese War under this roof, and wrote 18 of his books in the library on the first floor.
It's now run by the National Park Service. The main house tour is excellent — guided, about 40 minutes, gets you into every room from TR's gun collection to the North Room where he met with presidents and kings. The Old Orchard Museum covers the Roosevelt family's life after TR. The grounds are free to wander — 80+ acres of trails, meadows, and bay views.
Practical Stuff
House tours are timed and fill up on weekends — book ahead at nps.gov/sahi. Grounds open at 9 AM, close at sunset. Parking is free. Plan 2–3 hours for the tour and grounds.
Worth knowing: Sagamore Hill is 1.5 miles from Audrey Avenue. Short drive. And if you want the full Roosevelt Oyster Bay experience, it pairs with the next stop — 10 minutes up the road.
Stop 5 · 2:00 PM
Walk the Roosevelt Bird Sanctuary.
The Theodore Roosevelt Sanctuary and Audubon Center sits right next door to Sagamore Hill and honestly might be the most underrated spot in Oyster Bay. It's the oldest songbird sanctuary in the United States — established in 1923 in Roosevelt's honor, four years after his death.
Twelve acres of trails wind through forest and wetlands. The Audubon Center runs wildlife education programs and keeps injured raptors on-site — you can see owls, hawks, and falcons up close. TR himself is buried at Young's Memorial Cemetery directly adjacent to the sanctuary; his gravesite is a short walk from the trails and is open to the public.
Even if you only have 30 minutes, it's a beautiful walk. The contrast — from the grand rooms of Sagamore Hill to the quiet woods where birds sing — is genuinely moving.
Stop 6 · 3:30 PM
Back to the harbor.
Theodore Roosevelt Memorial Park sits right on Oyster Bay harbor. There's a small beach, a long pier, picnic tables, and one of the best sunset views on the North Shore. In spring and summer the harbor is full of sailboats. Grab a bench, stretch your legs, watch the water.
This is also where OysterFest happens every October — the region's largest waterfront festival. Worth knowing about for future trips.
Stop 7 · 4:30 PM · Yours Truly
Land at the brewery.
You've done a lot today. You've earned a Barn Rocker. We've been on Audrey Avenue since 2012, pouring beer brewed 30 feet from the bar, and we've seen every kind of day-tripper walk through the door.
Most of them leave happy.
The taproom is a short walk from the harbor. Open till midnight on Saturdays. Full draft list, rotating specialty pours, cocktails with Montauk Spirits. You did the history and the trails — now do the beer.
The Quick Version
Day at a Glance
This is the version we'd recommend to someone doing Oyster Bay for the first time. There's a lot we left out — the small shops we don't want to spoil for you, the good restaurants on Audrey we'd rather you discover on your own, the places only worth visiting in specific weather. Come back a second time and we'll tell you the rest.
Until then: come down. We'll save you a seat.
Leave a comment